
Accounting firms have spent years increasing starting salaries to attract talent. But once employees are hired, what makes them stay?
In the opening episode of The Talent Behind the Firm, a new series from The INSIDE Public Accounting Podcast, executive director Chelsea Summers and co-host Rob Brown examine how compensation, benefits and career development influence employee retention.
Drawing on IPA’s 2026 Human Resources Report, they explore why firms need to consider the full employee experience when deciding where to invest in their people.
The Cost of Losing Talent
Replacing an employee can cost between 50% and 200% of their annual salary. With average entry-level staff pay at approximately $68,000, even one departure can carry a substantial price tag.
And despite rising salaries, professional staff turnover remains at 11.8%, with 70% of departures voluntary.
Summers argues that firm leaders need to understand what turnover costs beyond recruiting fees, including lost client knowledge, additional work for remaining employees and interrupted mentoring.
Those costs provide a starting point for evaluating investments in retention.
Compensation Beyond the Paycheck
Summers introduces what she calls the “talent equation,” which accounts for base pay, raises, bonuses, benefits, time off, professional development and career opportunities.
While firms have raised starting salaries significantly over the past two decades, annual increases are moderating. The average raise for employees with up to two years of experience fell from 9.2% in 2023 to 5.7% in 2026.
The hosts discuss how firms can use merit-based increases to recognize performance and review their benefits to better support employees at different career stages.
For example, just 11% of firms offer childcare assistance and 5% provide elder care leave. Those benefits could be particularly valuable to mid-career professionals managing family responsibilities.
But even an attractive benefit depends on how employees experience it. Unlimited PTO, for instance, offers limited value when employees feel discouraged from taking time off.
“If partners are never taking time off, then nobody else is going to either,” Summers says.
Give Employees a Reason to Stay
One of the episode’s clearest opportunities comes from a simple conversation. According to IPA’s data, 87% of firms conduct exit interviews, while just 45% conduct stay interviews.
Rather than waiting for an employee to resign, Summers recommends asking what keeps people at the firm and what might make them leave. Those conversations can reveal concerns about compensation, advancement or workplace culture while there’s still time to respond.
The hosts also encourage firms to make their investment in employees more visible. A total rewards statement can show the full value of compensation, benefits, training and retirement contributions, giving employees a clearer understanding of what their firm provides.
Ultimately, retention also depends on whether employees can picture a future with the organization. That means explaining career paths, developing leadership skills and helping staff understand how the firm operates.
